Little recording decisions are more distinctive than melodies.
I keep a page in my notebook called tricks, and it has nothing to do with songs. It is a list of production decisions: a snare with too much room, a vocal double-tracked slightly off, a bass that slides into the next note, a guitar panned hard left with nothing on the right. Every time I notice one in a clip I write it down.
After a few weeks the list becomes a diagnostic tool. When I hear a clip I cannot place, I run down the list. Is the vocal doubled? Is there a slide in the bass? Is the drum machine from the eighties or from a modern plugin? Each question eliminates things. I am not trying to identify one trick in particular, I am trying to characterise the recording, and character is easier than identity.
The reason this works is that melodies are shared and production decisions are personal. Ten songs can have almost the same melody. Only one of them has a vocal buried under a specific reverb at that particular level. Producers have signatures, and those signatures leak into every song they touch.
My favourite entry from this month is "chorus arrives before the beat drops", which I keep hearing in modern pop. My least favourite entry is "no bass at all in the first bar", which has fooled me twice and which I now listen for.
None of this requires knowing music theory. It requires deciding that the sound of a recording is worth paying attention to, which is the same decision that makes the whole hobby interesting.
If you want to start a trick notebook, put down one entry after every round on the daily music puzzle for a week and see what you end up with.
If you want the fastest possible version of this exercise, do it in the practice lane and write the guess down before you check. The writing is what makes it data instead of a feeling, and the feeling is what got you the wrong answer in the first place. The notebook pairs naturally with browsing past songs and checking which trick keeps turning up.