Hints Are a Skill, Not a Crutch

The way you use a hint matters more than whether you use one.

There are two ways to use hints on the hint page, and they produce opposite results. The first is to open the page the moment you are stuck and read down to the line that gives it away. You get the answer and learn nothing. The second is to open one rung at a time and stop the moment you have a real guess. That is the version that makes you better.

The difference is that a hint is information, and information has to arrive at the right moment to be useful. Reading the first rung when you have a guess in mind tests the guess. Reading the fourth rung after giving up teaches you the answer but not the reasoning. The middle rungs, used deliberately, are where the learning is.

My rule is that each hint has to buy me a specific new fact. Rung one might tell me the era. If I already suspected the era, that rung was free and told me nothing, so I should have skipped it and played another round instead. Rung two might tell me the genre. That is genuinely new, and it should change my guess. If it does not change my guess, I am not using it.

I also keep a rule about streaks: if I use hints two days in a row, the third day is a hint-free day even if I lose. Streaks of hint-free days are a better measure of skill than streaks of wins, because wins can be bought with hints.

The whole system works because the hints are ordered, which is a design choice I appreciate. It means you can choose how much help you want with some precision, instead of getting either nothing or everything.

Start with today's puzzle and try only the first rung on your stuck days. Notice how far that gets you.

There is a social part to this too. When I admit to a friend that I used one hint, they usually admit they used three, and we both feel better. The shame around hints is mostly manufactured, and dropping it makes people play more and improve faster.